Monday, February 12, 2018

The New Pro-Life Movement and Its Critics

Since its inception in 2016, the New Pro-Life Movement has drawn criticism from conservative Catholic writers, not least because the NPLM began with the rejection of the old guard’s unhealthy attachment to conservative/Republican politics. The most recent attack, coming from the Charismatic Episcopal Church’s CEC for Life blog, had some me-too reprinting from Life Site News and Church Militant just as Crux Now published an interview with M.T. Dávila, an NPLM member and associate professor of Christian ethics at Andover Newton Theological Seminary. While some of CEC for Life’s criticisms are worth considering, more of them show why the old movement needs in-house censure.

Semantics Matter

Let’s begin with what the CEC for Life article gets right:

Under the NPLM’s “Women’s Rights and Justice” section of its 11 Pillars, the first paragraph begins, “Since women are the central figures in the abortion debate ….” Women are at the center, sure; they’re certainly not irrelevant to the debate. But neither are the unborn, who are also at the center of the debate. This particular phrasing simply begs to be misunderstood as saying the unborn and their right to life are of secondary consideration. The effect of legal abortion rights on fathers also gets no attention, enhancing this error.

Semantics matter. Murphy’s Law for Writers holds that “whatever can be misunderstood will be misunderstood, usually in the worst way possible.” Granting that opponents will deliberately misrepresent your position, you still write to be understood by those who rely on your words as you state them. Unlike a person in a casual conversation, the writer can’t afford to metaphorically let words just fall out of their mouths under the assumption, “Oh, they’ll know what I mean.” A political manifesto is the last place to be careless in your phrasing.

I’m well aware that no one in the NPLM sets a lower value on the unborn’s life than they do on the mother’s. But I’m not the one that has to be convinced.

Also, CEC for Life points out that, whatever the national leaders of the old movement do, there are more and more localized efforts to address the “demand” side of the abortion equation. “Ultimately, ... [the NPLM] fails to acknowledge a long-standing history of compassion and hard labor made evident through the hundreds and thousands of resources now available for mothers and fathers and their preborn child. Not to mention counseling and services available to abortion workers looking for healing and a new life.” The NPLM would do well to acknowledge these contributions and limit its criticism to the national leadership.

Hypercritical? Or Just Critical?

However, even when CEC for Life is right, the author of the statement ruins the point through hyperbole and sly hints that maybe founders Rebecca Bratten Weiss and Matthew Tyson have some other agenda in mind. [Full disclosure: I was Matthew’s managing editor when he wrote for Catholic Stand; we remain in contact through Facebook.]

This starts right at the beginning with the invocation of Abolish Human Abortion, a comparison which is invidious as most of NPLM’s members, including Bratten Weiss and Tyson, are Catholics who support the Church’s teaching magisterium and social doctrine.

The NPLM is the cheery version of AHA, who wants to work with everyone (as long as they didn’t vote for Trump), but remains publicly hypercritical of the current movement. Like AHA, they too, believe the movement has failed — but not because we are too soft.  Rather, because the movement is too hard. Too narrowly focused. And more Republican than they can stand.

The term hypercritical implies that the NPLM’s criticism of the GOP and the old guard’s association with it is to some degree overboard, in the same way that pro-choice advocates typically describe the pro-life movement inter alia as “far-right wing.” This simply begs for a defense of the movement’s association with the GOP and backing of Pres. Trump, or even a candid admission of the extent to which the criticism is justifiable. But the CEC for Life writer gives us neither: the NPLA is “hypercritical” simply by dint of being critical, as if the movement establishment were beyond reproach.

Too Picky? Not Picky Enough?

This Republican defensiveness comes up again later when the CEC for Life writer accuses the NPLM of a hypocritical stance:

The NPLM prefers the phrases “consistent life ethic” or “whole-life ethic.” They state that a “true pro-life ideology focuses on more than just abortion,” which refers to their 11 Pillars. If you aren’t willing to support all of their positions — including universal healthcare and preventing climate change — then you aren’t really pro-life. (And again, if you voted for Trump, just leave now.)

… There’s room for an “ethical pro-choicer” — whatever that is — to sit at the table. But if you are already pro-life, suddenly the standard flies skyward. There is no middle ground on gun control, or healthcare, or the environment — issues on which pro-lifers have always held varying opinions with no trouble.

But wait a minute! How does the NPLM find room at the table for pro-choicers?

See, the CEC for Life writer agonizes over the NPLM’s willingness to work with pro-choicers on other issues under their umbrella, such as universal health care and social safety-net programs. Of course, the writer explains to us, that’s a waste of time because the Hillary Clintons and Cecile Richardses of the pro-abortion faction are unreasonable and unreachable. “To shy away from the idea of a culture war in order to more fully embrace the opposition is not only an error in judgment, but a fatal flaw that will ensure failure. There is simply no common ground for murder.”

Nowhere and at no time has any NPLM representative said they’re unwilling to work with the establishment or embrace members who are less than 100% enthusiastic about the 11 Pillars. CEC for Life’s accusation is a hideous exaggeration based on a single line about a “true pro-life ideology”, which at best could be deemed subtly antagonistic (again, semantics) without stretching credulity. More to the point, CEC for Life has accused the NPLM of being at once too picky about their potential allies and not picky enough. Which is it? Or is any stick good enough to beat them with?

Reducing the Demand

Much of the opposition to the New Pro-Life Movement targets its “whole life ethic”; the most absurd and slanderous criticism ever made is that the NPLM is a pro-choice sabotage looking to “kitchen sink” the established movement to death with extraneous causes. The argument could be made — and has been made ad nauseam — that the priority of life establishes a natural hierarchy of concerns for the movement. In practice, however, that “natural hierarchy” simply means any policy or program which doesn’t suit the GOP agenda disappears from the establishment radar, even if that policy or program could reduce the demand for abortion.

That there is a demand for abortion should not be questioned. But the existence of a demand for an abortion, like the existence of a demand for illicit drugs, means that merely illegalizing the supply won’t make abortion go away; the clinics will just take up residence in the back alleys again. Elizabeth Bruenig pointed out some years ago, “If a woman considers herself too destitute to care for a child, there is no transvaginal ultrasound demoralizing enough and no accompanying narration excoriating enough to make her decision [to abort] seem any less plausible.” Reduce the demand, and support for the supply will weaken.

But what about the pillars that don’t touch on abortion demand, such as just war, the environment, and gun control? Again, this goes to the credibility of the movement, the question of whether the movement is really pro-life or just “pro-birth”. Threats to life come in many different forms, not all of them as direct as euthanasia or abortion, and some of which are driven by economic greed. While Prof. Dávila correctly points out that “the March for Life cannot become the March for Everything that is Unjust,” limiting the movement’s interests to abortion, euthanasia, and doctor-assisted suicide is hardly enough to qualify as “building a culture of life”.

Making Common Cause

The point of reducing the demand for abortion is reducing the perceived “need”, if you will, for its legality. But there is another point toward working with abortion supporters on other action items:

Simply put, as long as there is a hard core of abortion supporters, the “mushy middle” — the 77% of Americans (more or less) who are not either solidly pro- or anti-abortion — will continue to be mushy. Not until we weaken by defection the bloc of “powerful people who [make] certain that abortion is entrenched in our society” will the reversal of Roe v. Wade and the end of the atrocity come into sight. And so long as we’re perceived as 1) “pro-birth but not pro-life” and 2) radically uninterested in the challenges to equality faced by women, the hard core will not listen to us.

This apparently doesn’t bother the CEC for Life writer. From their perspective, the Hillary Clintons and Cecile Richardses of the pro-abortion faction are unreasonable and unreachable, so we should waste no effort trying to work with them on anything. But it’s precisely these people that keep organizations like Planned Parenthood and NARAL going, so it’s precisely these people we have to convert to the pro-life cause. Given that they are our opponents on the abortion issue, it doesn’t follow that we must be enemies on every issue; that’s the same kind of black-and-white thinking of which they accused the NPLM (if you’re not 100% with us, you’re against us).

Conclusion

If CEC for Life is bothered by the NPLM’s disparagement of Donald Trump and the Republicans, they should consider that the Republican-dominated Congress is yet again funding Planned Parenthood. The Party of Donald Trump bears little resemblance to the Party of Ronald Reagan; post-Christian libertarian populism (with heavy doses of white racism) has largely replaced the Christian neo-conservatism that once drove the Republican core. To the GOP, the pro-life movement is little more than a particular bloc of useful idiots and has been for some time. The movement doesn’t have to settle for being the Republicans’ side piece.

CEC for Life admits that “there is no problem in changing tactics to win any war; sometimes a tactical change is necessary.” But it’s not the tactics that need changing; rather, it’s the strategy. While the reversal of Roe v. Wade is still a proper goal, everything that supports the demand for abortion must be undermined; otherwise, even a friendly SCOTUS won’t repeal Roe’s core holding, as was demonstrated in Webster v. Reproductive Health Services. The political landscape has changed in the thirty years since Webster. It’s time for the movement to change as well.